Should I tell the truth to Natty in Hogwarts Legacy?

After the Hogwarts Legacy prologue, you carry the secrets of ancient magic with you, but should you tell Natty the truth? Natsai Onai or “Natty”is one of the first students you meet. You can also do school chores with her and get to know her. She even tells you about her life before entering Hogwarts. Building that friendship with her can influence your decision to tell her the truth or not. Let’s find out more about this.

Should I confess to Natty in Hogwarts Legacy?

In Hogwarts Legacy, Natty will ask you to meet in Lower Hogsfield after you get to know her. When you meet her here, she will ask you about what happened in Hogsmeade. Here are the options you will receive as answers:

• They want something that I found.
• I can not tell.

If you choose the first option and tell the truth, Natty will learn about ancient magic. She will tell you that she doesn’t know what it is. She will still trust you.

If you choose the second option and hide the truth, Natty will believe you, but she will also find it strange. She will still understand that you have your own reasons.

So, ultimately, it doesn’t matter what you decide to say to Natty in Hogwarts Legacy. It’s more like immersion and the only difference between the two is the different dialogues you get from it. While this can be a little disappointing, it’s also good that you can’t mess up your playthrough by choosing the wrong option. Often in games, such decisions can lead to the death of the character and the like. There is no such thing in Hogwarts Legacy.

So rest assured that no matter if you tell the truth, your relationship with Natty will remain the same. For more Hogwarts Legacy guides like this, check out our other articles.